Top Picks

• Best Overall: Forgotten Sisters: A Novel – $3.99
• Best Value: Stories I Forgot: A Chicago Horror Collection – $13.99
• Best for Historical Horror: The Ghosts of Chicago: Expanded Edition – $9.99
• Best for Psychological Horror: The House That Horror Built – $12.42
• Best for Supernatural Elements: Angel of Death – $6.99
• Best for Humor and Horror: Suburban Hell – $4.99
• Best for Gothic Horror: This Cursed House – $14.99
• Best for Time Travel Horror: The Shining Girls: A Novel – $8.99
• Best for Werewolf Horror: Saamaanthaa (The Wolfshadow Trilogy Book 1) – $3.99
• Best for Urban Fantasy Horror: Storm Front (The Dresden Files, Book 1) – $21.18

Selection Criteria

When selecting these horror novels, I focused on their connection to Chicago, the depth of their storytelling, and the unique elements that set them apart in the genre. Each book offers a different perspective on fear, making them perfect for various tastes in horror.

Forgotten Sisters: A Novel

Disclaimer: Cynthia Pelayo has done interviews, guest posts, and more for Horror Tree in the past, and while I might be biased, it is easy to see why any of her work could fall into the best overall novel on this list.

Dive into the haunting world of ‘Forgotten Sisters,’ where the eerie atmosphere of Chicago intertwines with a gripping tale of mystery and ghostly encounters. This novel follows sisters Anna and Jennie, who live in a historic bungalow along the Chicago River, a place steeped in family history and unsettling secrets. As bodies begin to surface in the river, Anna’s podcast about ghost stories becomes a lifeline, drawing her into a web of intrigue and danger. With its blend of psychological suspense and elements of fairy tales, this book is perfect for those cozy nights when you want to be captivated by a story that lingers long after the last page. Whether you’re a fan of horror or just looking for a unique read, ‘Forgotten Sisters’ offers a compelling escape into a world where the past and present collide.

What People Say

Readers appreciate the unique combination of ghost stories and psychological suspense, often highlighting the vivid descriptions of Chicago and the emotional depth of the characters. Many find themselves captivated by the intricate plot that weaves together the sisters’ personal struggles with the haunting history of their home.

• Cynthia Pelayo’s writing is immersive, drawing readers into the haunting atmosphere of Chicago. The blend of ghostly elements with a gripping mystery kept me hooked from start to finish. The character development is rich, especially with the sisters’ complex relationship and their connection to the house they inhabit.– María J. Estrada

Why You’ll Love This Book

• Engaging blend of horror and mystery
• Rich character development
• Atmospheric setting in Chicago
• Unique storytelling with fairy tale elements

When to Read

Perfect for a night in when you’re looking for a chilling read that will keep you on the edge of your seat. It’s also a great choice for book clubs, sparking discussions about themes of family, loss, and the supernatural.

Current Price: $3.99

Rating: 3.4 (Total: 305+)

Buy Now

Stories I Forgot: A Chicago Horror Collection

Step into the chilling world of ‘Stories I Forgot,’ where the vibrant yet haunting streets of Chicago serve as the backdrop for a collection of interconnected horror tales and poems. This book dives deep into the darker aspects of human nature, blending real-life brutalities with supernatural elements that will linger in your mind long after you’ve turned the last page. Whether you’re curled up on the couch or gathered with friends for a spooky night in, this collection is perfect for those who appreciate a mix of emotional depth and spine-tingling storytelling. If you’re looking for a unique read that captures the essence of urban horror, this one is a must-have.

What People Say

Readers rave about the emotional impact of the stories, often highlighting how they resonate with real-life issues while still delivering a thrilling horror experience. Many appreciate the author’s ability to weave together nostalgia and fresh perspectives, making it a compelling read for both horror aficionados and casual readers alike.

• Chaz Williams’ collection is a poignant reflection on the real horrors faced in urban life, framed within the chilling context of Chicago. The stories are not just scary; they evoke a range of emotions, making you think deeply about the themes of violence and humanity. The blend of poetry adds an extra layer of depth that truly sets this collection apart.– Emiray

Why You’ll Love This Collection

• Unique blend of urban horror and poetry
• Thought-provoking themes about humanity
• Vivid portrayal of Chicago’s darker side
• Interconnected stories that create a cohesive narrative

When to Read

Ideal for those late-night reading sessions when you want something that will keep you on the edge of your seat. It’s also a fantastic choice for book clubs, as it opens up discussions about societal issues and personal fears, all wrapped in a gripping narrative.

Current Price: $13.99

Rating: 4.4 (Total: 23+)

Buy Now

The Ghosts of Chicago: Expanded Edition

Dive into the eerie depths of Chicago’s haunted history with ‘The Ghosts of Chicago: Expanded Edition.’ This book is a treasure trove of spine-tingling tales, meticulously researched by Adam Selzer, who brings the city’s ghostly lore to life. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this book offers a unique perspective on the city’s darker side, making it perfect for a cozy night in or a thrilling book club discussion. With new chapters and updates, it’s a fresh take on a classic that will keep you engaged and entertained.

What People Say

Readers appreciate the blend of humor and thorough research, often noting how Selzer’s engaging storytelling makes the ghostly tales come alive. Many find the new edition’s updates and additional stories enhance their reading experience, making it a must-have for anyone interested in Chicago’s haunted past.

• Adam Selzer’s writing is both informative and humorous, making the ghost stories of Chicago not just spooky but also enjoyable. His deep dive into research shines through, and the updated edition adds even more fascinating details that keep you hooked from start to finish.– Nutcracker

Why You’ll Enjoy This Book

• In-depth exploration of Chicago’s ghost stories
• Engaging writing style that blends humor with history
• Updated content with new research and photos
• Perfect for both casual readers and history buffs

When to Read

This book is ideal for those chilly nights when you’re looking for something to send shivers down your spine. It’s also a fantastic choice for gatherings with friends who enjoy a good scare, or for anyone wanting to learn more about the rich history of Chicago’s ghost lore.

Current Price: $9.99

Rating: 4.6 (Total: 24+)

Buy Now

The House That Horror Built

Step into the chilling world of ‘The House That Horror Built’ by Christina Henry, where a single mother finds herself working in the gothic mansion of a reclusive horror director. This gripping tale is packed with suspense and eerie secrets that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Perfect for those cozy nights when you want to dive into a story that blends horror with a touch of heart, this book is a must-read for fans of the genre. Whether you’re a horror aficionado or just looking for a thrilling escape, this novel promises to deliver a captivating experience.

What People Say

Readers rave about the atmospheric writing and the relatable struggles of the protagonist, Harry. Many appreciate how the story balances horror elements with emotional depth, making it not just a scary read but also a poignant one. The references to horror films resonate well with fans, adding an extra layer of enjoyment.

• Christina Henry knows how to build an atmosphere… The story revolves around Harry, a single mom who takes a job cleaning for a horror director, and as she uncovers secrets in the house, the tension builds beautifully. The character development is fantastic, and the references to classic horror films add a delightful layer for genre fans.– G. Poirier

Why You’ll Love This Book

• Engaging plot that intertwines horror and personal struggles
• Rich character development and atmospheric storytelling
• References to classic horror films that fans will appreciate
• Perfect for both casual readers and horror enthusiasts

When to Read

This book is ideal for those late-night reading sessions when you’re looking for something that sends chills down your spine. It’s also a great pick for book clubs or gatherings with friends who enjoy discussing horror themes and character arcs, making it a versatile addition to your reading list.

Current Price: $12.42

Rating: 3.5 (Total: 403+)

Buy Now

Angel of Death

Dive into the dark and twisted world of ‘Angel of Death’ by J. Robert King, where the lines between good and evil blur in the gritty streets of Chicago. This gripping tale follows an angel tasked with managing death in the city, who finds himself entangled in a web of murder and love. With a unique premise that combines supernatural elements with a crime thriller, this book is perfect for those who enjoy a chilling narrative that keeps you guessing. Whether you’re a fan of horror or just looking for a captivating read, this novel offers a blend of suspense and philosophical musings that will keep you turning the pages.

What People Say

Readers appreciate the intricate storytelling and the moral questions posed by the protagonist’s journey. Many highlight the book’s ability to weave together suspense and supernatural themes, making it a thought-provoking read that resonates long after the last page.

• This book is a ripping good yarn, reminiscent of old pulp detective stories but with much more depth. The main character, an angel, faces moral dilemmas while managing deaths in Chicago, and the plot twists keep you engaged throughout. The pacing is excellent, making it hard to put down.– Lewis Woolston

Why You’ll Enjoy This Book

• Unique blend of supernatural and crime thriller elements
• Engaging character development with moral complexities
• Intriguing plot twists that keep you on your toes
• Perfect for fans of horror and philosophical narratives

When to Read

This book is ideal for those late-night reading sessions when you’re in the mood for something dark and thought-provoking. It’s also a great choice for book clubs or discussions about morality and the nature of good and evil, making it a versatile addition to your reading list.

Current Price: $6.99

Rating: 3.3 (Total: 42+)

Buy Now

Suburban Hell

Step into the eerie suburban landscape of ‘Suburban Hell’ by Maureen Kilmer, where a seemingly ordinary cul-de-sac becomes the backdrop for a demonic possession. This novel blends humor and horror as a group of suburban moms band together to confront the supernatural forces threatening their friend and their neighborhood. With relatable characters and a plot that balances everyday life with spine-chilling events, it’s perfect for those who enjoy a good scare mixed with a dose of laughter. Whether you’re looking for a thrilling read or a fun book club pick, this one will keep you entertained and on the edge of your seat.

What People Say

Readers appreciate the fun and relatable take on suburban life intertwined with horror elements. Many highlight the book’s ability to balance humor with genuine scares, making it a refreshing addition to the horror genre that resonates with moms and horror fans alike.

• I loved the premise of this book! It’s a campy, over-the-top horror story that captures the essence of suburban life while introducing a supernatural twist. The characters are relatable, and the humor adds a delightful layer to the creepy moments. It’s exactly what I want from this type of horror.– Kristen Claiborn

Why You’ll Enjoy This Book

• Unique blend of horror and humor
• Relatable characters that reflect everyday suburban life
• Engaging plot with a mix of suspense and comedic moments
• Perfect for fans of campy horror and strong female friendships

When to Read

This book is ideal for those cozy nights when you want a mix of laughter and chills. It’s also a fantastic choice for book clubs, sparking discussions about friendship, motherhood, and the supernatural, making it a versatile read for various occasions.

Current Price: $4.99

Rating: 3.8 (Total: 430+)

Buy Now

This Cursed House

Dive into the haunting world of ‘This Cursed House’ by Del Sandeen, a gripping Southern gothic horror novel that explores the dark secrets of a mysterious family in New Orleans. Set against the backdrop of 1960s Chicago, the story follows Jemma Barker, a young Black woman who takes a job with the Duchon family, only to uncover their chilling curse. With its rich atmosphere and complex characters, this book is perfect for those who enjoy a blend of historical depth and spine-tingling suspense. Whether you’re curled up on a rainy night or looking for a book to discuss with friends, this novel promises to keep you captivated and on the edge of your seat.

What People Say

Readers are drawn to the intricate storytelling and the way it tackles serious themes like racism and family secrets within a horror framework. Many highlight the author’s ability to create a haunting atmosphere that lingers long after the last page is turned.

• This is a very well written book. And because of that, it had to be researched. It is a serious book, and believe it or not, the paranormal lightens the story. I look forward to future books.– smhunter

Why You’ll Love This Book

• Engaging narrative that blends horror with historical themes
• Richly developed characters that resonate with readers
• Atmospheric setting that immerses you in the story
• Explores deep social issues while delivering chills

When to Read

This book is perfect for those late-night reading sessions when you crave a good scare. It’s also an excellent choice for book clubs, as it opens up discussions about history, culture, and the complexities of family dynamics, making it a thought-provoking read for various occasions.

Current Price: $14.99

Rating: 4.2 (Total: 235+)

Buy Now

The Shining Girls: A Novel

Step into the chilling narrative of ‘The Shining Girls’ by Lauren Beukes, a unique blend of horror and time travel set in the gritty backdrop of Chicago. This novel follows Kirby Mazrachi, the girl who survives a brutal attack by a serial killer named Harper Curtis, who has the eerie ability to travel through time. As Kirby seeks to uncover the truth behind her attempted murder, the story weaves through different decades, revealing the lives of the other ‘shining girls’ targeted by Harper. With its gripping plot and richly drawn characters, this book is perfect for those cozy nights when you want to be both thrilled and unnerved. Whether you’re a horror aficionado or just looking for a captivating read, this novel will keep you turning pages long into the night.

What People Say

Readers are captivated by the unique premise and the way Beukes intertwines horror with historical elements. Many appreciate the depth of the characters and the emotional weight of the story, which lingers long after reading.

• Before anything else, let me say this book is excellently written with fantastic characters that feel real to the reader. It’s a story that will absolutely hold your interest, and is hard to put down. All that being said, it’s also extremely disturbing, and dark on a level you rarely find.– Amazon Customer

Why You’ll Love This Book

• Innovative blend of horror and time travel
• Strong character development that resonates with readers
• Engaging narrative that keeps you guessing
• Explores deep themes of survival and trauma

When to Read

This book is ideal for those late-night reading sessions when you’re in the mood for something spine-chilling. It’s also a fantastic pick for book clubs, sparking discussions about the complexities of time, fate, and the impact of violence on women.

Current Price: $8.99

Rating: 4.0 (Total: 3697+)

Buy Now

Saamaanthaa (The Wolfshadow Trilogy Book 1)

Dive into the eerie world of ‘Saamaanthaa’ by D. T. Neal, where horror meets the vibrant streets of Chicago. This novel follows Samantha Hain, a performance artist whose life takes a dark turn after a fateful encounter with a werewolf. As she grapples with her new identity and the monstrous urges that come with it, the story unfolds in a blend of dark humor and chilling horror. Perfect for those late-night reading sessions, this book offers a unique take on the werewolf mythos while exploring themes of identity and societal norms. Whether you’re a horror enthusiast or just looking for a gripping read, ‘Saamaanthaa’ will keep you on the edge of your seat.

What People Say

Readers appreciate the fresh take on werewolf lore and the depth of the characters. Many find the exploration of Samantha’s dual nature both fascinating and relatable, making it a standout in the horror genre.

• D. T. Neal’s writing is modern and direct, drawing you into the world of Samantha Hain. The characters are well-drawn, and the plot is both engaging and thought-provoking, making you reflect on the nature of humanity and monstrosity.– Miss_Motley

Why You’ll Love This Book

• Unique blend of horror and dark comedy
• Rich character development that resonates with readers
• Explores complex themes of identity and societal expectations
• Set against the backdrop of Chicago’s vibrant art scene

When to Read

This book is perfect for those nights when you want to be both entertained and unnerved. It’s also a great choice for book clubs, sparking discussions about the nature of humanity and the complexities of modern life.

Current Price: $3.99

Rating: 3.5 (Total: 19+)

Buy Now

Storm Front (The Dresden Files, Book 1)

Step into the thrilling world of ‘Storm Front’ by Jim Butcher, where magic and mystery collide in the bustling streets of Chicago. This first installment in the Dresden Files series introduces you to Harry Dresden, a wizard and private investigator who navigates the dark underbelly of the supernatural. As he investigates a gruesome double murder linked to black magic, you’ll find yourself immersed in a fast-paced narrative filled with humor, suspense, and a touch of romance. It’s a perfect read for those late nights when you crave a blend of action and the supernatural, making it an ideal companion for horror enthusiasts and mystery lovers alike.

What People Say

Readers rave about the witty writing and the unique blend of humor and horror. Many appreciate how Butcher crafts a vivid world where magic feels both real and relatable, making Harry Dresden a character you can’t help but root for.

• This book hooked me even when I still hated to read. It’s suspenseful, comical, and sarcastic even through the serious themes, making relatable story arcs out of fantastic circumstances. I couldn’t stop reading Dresden.– Margaret Markey

Why You’ll Enjoy This Book

• Engaging mix of urban fantasy and detective noir
• Relatable characters with depth and humor
• Fast-paced plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat
• Richly detailed supernatural elements set in Chicago

When to Dive In

This book is perfect for cozy nights in when you want to be entertained and a little spooked. It’s also a fantastic pick for book clubs, sparking lively discussions about morality, magic, and the human experience.

Current Price: $21.18

Rating: 4.4 (Total: 30852+)

Buy Now

FAQ

What should I consider before buying a horror novel set in Chicago?

Before purchasing a horror novel set in Chicago, think about your personal preferences in horror. Do you enjoy supernatural elements, psychological thrillers, or a mix of both? Also, consider the author’s writing style and the book’s reviews. Checking ratings and reader feedback can give you insight into whether the book will resonate with you. If you’re sensitive to graphic content, it’s wise to read reviews that mention the level of violence or horror depicted. Lastly, think about the setting; if you love Chicago, look for novels that incorporate its unique history and culture, as this can enhance your reading experience.

How can I make the most of my reading experience with these horror novels?

To fully immerse yourself in these spine-chilling horror novels, create a cozy reading environment. Find a comfortable spot, perhaps with dim lighting, and consider having a warm drink nearby. If you’re reading at night, the atmosphere can enhance the suspense. Additionally, take breaks to reflect on the story and its characters; this can deepen your engagement. If you enjoy discussing books, consider joining a book club or online forum where you can share your thoughts and hear others’ perspectives. This can add a social element to your reading journey and help you appreciate the nuances of the story.

Are these horror novels suitable for all readers?

While many horror novels can appeal to a broad audience, not all are suitable for every reader. If you’re new to the genre, start with books that have a mix of suspense and character development rather than extreme horror. Pay attention to content warnings regarding violence, gore, or themes that might be distressing. If you’re unsure, reading sample chapters or reviews can help you gauge whether a book aligns with your comfort level. Remember, horror can be subjective; what terrifies one person may not affect another, so trust your instincts when choosing a book.

Wrapping Up

These ten horror novels set in Chicago not only provide thrilling narratives but also explore the complexities of fear, history, and human nature. Whether you prefer ghost stories, psychological thrillers, or supernatural tales, there’s something here for every horror enthusiast. Dive into these chilling reads and discover the darker side of the Windy City.